What we owed
we had five ways to find the truth
and enough money for four drinks.
Alder said
if you can’t test it,
stop arguing.
so we tested the whisky.
it was whisky.
we tested it again
because we liked to be careful
with conclusions.
“does she still love you?” my mate asked.
“that isn’t testable.”
“you could go home.”
I ordered another experiment.
Hume wouldn’t swallow a miracle
just because some bastard
had learned to tell it well.
a man at the bar said
he’d found God
and given up drinking.
he was drinking water.
we watched him
with the hatred men reserve
for evidence.
Grice said there was more to meaning
than the words.
“you don’t have to leave,”
she’d told me,
her hand still on my sleeve.
I admired the precision of that.
I didn’t have to.
so I left.
for years I said
I had understood her perfectly.
there are men doing life
with a better defence.
Rand wanted the labels
to earn their keep.
don’t split what belongs together.
don’t lump together
what needs to be kept apart.
I had thirty names for my drinking
and one for hers.
mine was grief,
pressure,
the cost of being a writer.
hers was weakness.
Feynman said
explain it simply.
I explained loneliness
with a theory of the mind,
three dead Germans
and something about the stars.
“you miss her,” my mate said.
“it’s not that simple.”
“is it wrong?”
outside,
a truck emptied the bins.
I waited for it to finish.
the barman put down the bill.
we examined it.
testable.
hard to doubt.
plain enough.
nothing counted twice.
even a child
could have explained it.
neither of us reached
for his wallet.